two models - two results
Boat in still water.
A man moves from one end of the boat to the other. Find the boat offset relative to the shore. We neglect the friction of the boat on the water and other so.
One is usually remembered that under such conditions the center of gravity (of the BOAT + MAN system) remains in place. And - after drawing a little - we got equation for the boat shift/offset:
(1)
Here L is length of the boat, m is mass of man, M is mass of boat.
Or - let say - "from first principles":
Those who remember only Newton's laws write that (in the inertial frame of reference associated with the shore) the product of the boat's mass M by its acceleration A is equal to the sum of all forces acting on the boat. And only the person (of mass m) who walks along the boat with acceleration a acts on it:
(2)
Integrating twice in time (from the beginning of the person's movement to his stopping, or to infinity, when everything stops), we get the products of masses and displacements (of a boat and a person) relative to the coast .
(3)
And since the displacement of a person relative to the coast is:
из (3) снова получаем (1)!
But suddenly ...
a clever man appears and said:
- What if we take into account the friction on water?
Well! Recall that for low velocities, the fluid friction force is proportional to the body's velocity V , and the proportionality coefficient k depends on the properties of the fluid, the size and shape of the body.
Now - according to Newton's laws - the product of the boat's mass M by its acceleration A is equal to the sum of two forces: from the person walking on the boat, and the force of liquid friction. Instead of (2) we have:
(2')
Integrating over time (from the beginning of a person's movement t = 0 to infinity, when everything stops), we get:
But all velocities - both the boat and the person - are equal to zero at t = 0 and at infinite time (when everything stops). Thus, for any k other than zero, the boat displacement is:
Confusion !!!